Champions!
Moderators: BillShankly, John Cena, swannsong, Forum Admins
Champions!
Well done Brahma for winning the Div 4 league yesterday! Top effort all round. Heard there was a few slurred words last night from all the jagers.
Enjoy the moment boys and come on the ressies! You can do it!!!!
Enjoy the moment boys and come on the ressies! You can do it!!!!
-
- Squad Player
- Posts: 1662
- Joined: Fri Mar 31, 2006 11:35 am
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 535
- Joined: Wed May 03, 2006 7:36 am
-
- Ball Boy
- Posts: 36
- Joined: Mon Jul 31, 2006 10:34 am
-
- Ball Boy
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 2:59 pm
-
- Apprentice
- Posts: 181
- Joined: Wed May 03, 2006 9:37 pm
- anfield road
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 799
- Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 10:53 pm
- Olympic (Vista) Bhoy
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 856
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:54 am
- Olympic (Vista) Bhoy
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 856
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:54 am
Congrat
Well done Brahma good luck in Div 3. I think the best thing you did to get this hapening was to appoint a coach that wanted to go somewhere, unlike one of your previous ones who has no idea how to coach on match days - initials NJ
Re: Congrat
thats a bit harsh... if those are the intials I think they are, then your wrong... I have been coached by him and was pretty much forced out of my last club by him, but I still think he is pretty damn good coach... but each to their own...Marco2 wrote:Well done Brahma good luck in Div 3. I think the best thing you did to get this hapening was to appoint a coach that wanted to go somewhere, unlike one of your previous ones who has no idea how to coach on match days - initials NJ

NJ - Good Trainer but can't COach
I think he is a great trainer, bur not a great coach. More specifically his training drills are very good and he has a great ability to get players fit. As for a coach though he lacks the ability to motivate and struggles in terms of tactics.
Whenever he has had success it has been more to do with having the right cattle as opposed to any great planning.
I think if he had this ability he would be coaching at a much higher level.
Whenever he has had success it has been more to do with having the right cattle as opposed to any great planning.
I think if he had this ability he would be coaching at a much higher level.
Re: NJ - Good Trainer but can't COach
I have a similar impression of him... that said I have been part of the reserves side this year and not his A team (except bench warming...)Marco2 wrote:I think he is a great trainer, bur not a great coach. More specifically his training drills are very good and he has a great ability to get players fit. As for a coach though he lacks the ability to motivate and struggles in terms of tactics.
Whenever he has had success it has been more to do with having the right cattle as opposed to any great planning.
I think if he had this ability he would be coaching at a much higher level.
Athelstone SC - http://www.athelstonesc.com
Based on the assumption he stays at ASC for the next few years will be the real test. As the competition gets stronger it will be a test on whether he has the ability to coach (as opposed to train) at this level.
As you guys are in Div 5, I think success has come primarily due to players, however these same players will need to step it up next season and a good training programme (i.e. fitness) alone will not be enough. I sincerely hope he does bring you guys success, but I wouldn't bank on it simply because when the chips are down I am not convinced (based on experience) that he is able to plan and plot new ways to win. Your stint in Div 3 is a glaring example of this. There were good players there but little game day preparation and direction.
Again ,this is why he isn't coaching Div 1 or 2, which is somehwat unfortunate as his ability to get players fit is second to none.
As you guys are in Div 5, I think success has come primarily due to players, however these same players will need to step it up next season and a good training programme (i.e. fitness) alone will not be enough. I sincerely hope he does bring you guys success, but I wouldn't bank on it simply because when the chips are down I am not convinced (based on experience) that he is able to plan and plot new ways to win. Your stint in Div 3 is a glaring example of this. There were good players there but little game day preparation and direction.
Again ,this is why he isn't coaching Div 1 or 2, which is somehwat unfortunate as his ability to get players fit is second to none.
I understand what you are saying marco2, but I think also you need to have the cattle to understand and follow the gaffer... its a bit hard for coach to prepare when say maybe some of his players have a low opinion of the person...
I think ASC if not breeze through div.4, will at least gain promotion to div.3 first time of asking simply because of the way he prepares his players, who are more than up to div.4 standard. It will be interesting to see how they go in Div.3 though...
It always interesting to see how former players (im guessing that you are a former player, or at least an observer of his methods first hand) talk about coaches that have come and gone... but I find it strange that someone who is still involved with the gaffer would agree with you... I'm a former player and would't say I left on the best of circumstances but still retain my high opinions of him because its deserved, but again... each to their own...
I think ASC if not breeze through div.4, will at least gain promotion to div.3 first time of asking simply because of the way he prepares his players, who are more than up to div.4 standard. It will be interesting to see how they go in Div.3 though...
It always interesting to see how former players (im guessing that you are a former player, or at least an observer of his methods first hand) talk about coaches that have come and gone... but I find it strange that someone who is still involved with the gaffer would agree with you... I'm a former player and would't say I left on the best of circumstances but still retain my high opinions of him because its deserved, but again... each to their own...

Higher Div Test
Fair points. I guess time wil tell. I do agree that they should make it to Div 3 at some point, this will be the test though.
At this point players need definite structure and team rules, as opposed to just roll up on Sunday and win because you are better and fitter than them.
This is where my question mark is with him. I too think he is a great bloke, however he hasn't acheived the success he should have, either because a lack of planning and strucutre or self-discipline - perhaps a combo of both?
At this point players need definite structure and team rules, as opposed to just roll up on Sunday and win because you are better and fitter than them.
This is where my question mark is with him. I too think he is a great bloke, however he hasn't acheived the success he should have, either because a lack of planning and strucutre or self-discipline - perhaps a combo of both?
No doubt... you defintately can't just be fitter and better, you need structure and planning... when I was at ASC, I felt there was a good structure for players to adhere to but I can't really comment on his planning pre-match because I wasn't his assistant or whatever.
I agree that Div.3 will be the real test, as that is where the amateur divisions are started to be taken more seriosuly somewhat... I do wish the boys at ASC the best of luck, its a pretty good team assembled, I guess it was a pity that I didn't really fit in too well with the team, but they are prolly better for it and so am I.
I agree that Div.3 will be the real test, as that is where the amateur divisions are started to be taken more seriosuly somewhat... I do wish the boys at ASC the best of luck, its a pretty good team assembled, I guess it was a pity that I didn't really fit in too well with the team, but they are prolly better for it and so am I.

-
- Squad Player
- Posts: 1662
- Joined: Fri Mar 31, 2006 11:35 am
You are dead right Marco2, NJ is a top bloke and has a farily good training program, but when it comes to game day he really didnt seem to have the 'fire in the belly'.
As for ASC, 2 years ago a fair few of the players who are there were wearing Brahma strips in Div 4, with NJ as the coach. 5th place was what they acheived. They also acheived the same thing last year with a new coach. Will be interesting to see how they go next year
As for ASC, 2 years ago a fair few of the players who are there were wearing Brahma strips in Div 4, with NJ as the coach. 5th place was what they acheived. They also acheived the same thing last year with a new coach. Will be interesting to see how they go next year
- Judge Judy
- Technical Director
- Posts: 35566
- Joined: Wed May 15, 2002 7:55 pm
-
- Squad Player
- Posts: 1662
- Joined: Fri Mar 31, 2006 11:35 am