One dayers

[Delete Your Account]

He walked!

And then he walked back,
for someone who wasn't interested in the one day series you sure have had a lot to say about it, most of it drivel as usual

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not.

Which Law of the Game relates to a batsman walking?

[God is an Englishman]

Which Law of the Game relates to a batsman walking?

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not

[God is an Englishman]

Alex Hales
Aggers
Ian Healy
David Warner
Hawkesy

There's 5 people who all believe he was out. 2 of those are aussies as well.

[Delete Your Account]

Which Law of the Game relates to a batsman walking?

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not

So, what's the answer? Which Law?

[God is an Englishman]

Which Law of the Game relates to a batsman walking?

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not

So, what's the answer? Which Law?

There is no law, it's the concept that you walk when you know you're out. Warner walked, he knew he was out. If he had any doubt then he would have stood and waited.

[WayneO]

Which Law of the Game relates to a batsman walking?

So, what's the answer? Which Law?

There is no law, it's the concept that you walk when you know you're out. Warner walked, he knew he was out. If he had any doubt then he would have stood and waited.

Warner walked because he hit the ball, and thought it was caught behind.
The POM wicket-keeper who cheated and claimed a catch which clearly hit the floor, and subsequently, Warner was called back as he is NOT OUT!

[predator]

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not.

I'm more concerned that cheating is rife in the English camp

[God is an Englishman]

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not.

I'm more concerned that cheating is rife in the English camp

Really? rife? Couldn't name 2 instances of cheating in the last year if I tried.

[God is an Englishman]

Warner walked because he hit the ball, and thought it was caught behind.
The POM wicket-keeper who cheated and claimed a catch which clearly hit the floor, and subsequently, Warner was called back as he is NOT OUT!

there you go, the bloke with the best view in the house believed he was out. Thanks for helping me out.

[ozzie owl]

Big achievement the English side wasn't bowled inside 50 overs.

[God is an Englishman]

Big achievement the English side wasn't bowled inside 50 overs.

Who were you supporting?

[God is an Englishman]

Channel 7 - The clubhouse. They can't believe he got called back, he was out. Seems like there's even a fair few aussies seeing reason now.

[swannsong]

There is no law, it's the concept that you walk when you know you're out. Warner walked, he knew he was out. If he had any doubt then he would have stood and waited.

Along with the concept of walking when you 'believe' you are out because you hit the ball (you have to rely on the catcher's honesty) is another concept that the catcher should not appeal unless 100% sure that it carrried....if there is doubt then the 'carried' side of the appeal is in the umpires hands....

[Ashes Whitewash]

The batsman walking only acknowledges he hit it.

[Bomber]

Do you understand the concept of walking as a batsmen? Clearly not.

I'm more concerned that cheating is rife in the English camp

Really? rife? Couldn't name 2 instances of cheating in the last year if I tried.

We know. Even if they were there you couldnt bring yourself to name them.

[God is an Englishman]

The batsman walking only acknowledges he hit it.

No, by walking he acknowledges that he was out.

[swannsong]

The batsman walking only acknowledges he hit it.

No, by walking he acknowledges that he was out.

DRS has removed player's 'certainty' that they were out....as I said before, relies heavily on the appealing team being honest....batsman probably would never contemplate walking if the opposition team signalled a ball had not carried. Do batsmen ever 'walk' on LBW, borderline stumpings etc...even if they believe they are out ?

[Old Redback]

Good thing about one dayers is that it is only one day of pain rather than 2 and a half.

[Bomber]

Good thing about one dayers is that it is only one day of pain rather than 2 and a half.

Fair played.

Bring on the T20's you reckon? Maybe just a few panadol could do the trick then.

[Bomber]

7 overs gone, poms 0/36.

Cook's even in still !

[God is an Englishman]

7 overs gone, poms 0/36.

Cook's even in still !

I'm confused here!

you can't have 36 wickets

how is cook in if australia are batting?

[God is an Englishman]

England 52-0 off 10

[God is an Englishman]

57-1 top drawer catch to get cook c+b maxwell

[adelaidebloke]

Root is rooted again

[Old Redback]

Brilliant knock by Morgan - showed some real flair - pity the rest of the English team hadn't shown the same this summer. Get him in the test side.

[ozzie owl]

England clinch defeat from the jaws of victory.

[predator]

England clinch defeat from the jaws of victory.

[MegaBonus]

honestly.....at what point does it stop being funny and you actually start feeling sorry for them??????????????

[Steve#4]

honestly.....at what point does it stop being funny and you actually start feeling sorry for them??????????????

I felt pitty for them after the third test...

[Bomber]

Hawkesy's been busy checking Faulkner's birthplace, parentage etc.......

5-0 + 2-0 = 7-0

Been a great tour so far.