Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
Moderators: BillShankly, arxidi, ruud, Judge Judy, Forum Admins
-
- First Team Regular
- Posts: 2100
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 11:34 am
Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
Make up your own mind.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1UihUqHKbU
In my opinion, they were all soft.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1UihUqHKbU
In my opinion, they were all soft.
- Chelsea4thewin
- Star Player
- Posts: 3159
- Joined: Mon Apr 06, 2009 1:49 pm
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
that handball by Pique makes me so sick
look at Anelka's face, he knows its a penalty, he doesnt even bother appealing for it because its as clear as day
look at Anelka's face, he knows its a penalty, he doesnt even bother appealing for it because its as clear as day
Chelsea4thewin wrote: if Torres doesnt score in the next 3 games i will put a liverpool symbol as my avatar for the rest of the season
-
- First Team Regular
- Posts: 2100
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 11:34 am
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
Agree with the Pique one, that should of been given.
The rest were very very soft.
The rest were very very soft.
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
The Pique one for sure.
Indirect free kick inside the box for the Malouda one. ( so they got more of an advantage IMO).
Shirt tugging 99% of the time doesn't get called ( Liverpool V Chelsea was, but that was some fierce shirt tugging).
Eto'o I'm not sold on, i don't like the idea that a player can block a ball with there arm, and because the arm was already there it's not a penalty. I should start blocking shots arms outstretched in that case and as long as my arms are there it should never be called. Players on the post should stand with arms outwide too in that case.
For mine Eto' was marginal too.
Indirect free kick inside the box for the Malouda one. ( so they got more of an advantage IMO).
Shirt tugging 99% of the time doesn't get called ( Liverpool V Chelsea was, but that was some fierce shirt tugging).
Eto'o I'm not sold on, i don't like the idea that a player can block a ball with there arm, and because the arm was already there it's not a penalty. I should start blocking shots arms outstretched in that case and as long as my arms are there it should never be called. Players on the post should stand with arms outwide too in that case.
For mine Eto' was marginal too.
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
agree, you have to wonder how the ref and linesman missed it though :? The Russian Mafia will be onto it as we speakA-Mac wrote:Agree with the Pique one, that should of been given.
The rest were very very soft.
- mattieg1200
- Squad Player
- Posts: 1701
- Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2006 4:15 pm
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
u have to say though.. was piques hand there before the ball was kicked into it ? if any had to be given it would have been that one but the rest were very soft.. and drogbas a bottle of shiraz cheating sherry anyway
R.I.P Robbo 8th June 2006
R.I.P Konny 1st July 2007
Liverpool-Champions of Europe 2005
R.I.P Konny 1st July 2007
Liverpool-Champions of Europe 2005
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
game is about goals, he was done by the defender more than just in the way of a rocket shot. Pique didn't appear to do it on purpose but I still think it denied a clear goal scoring opportunity and therefore worthy of a spot kick.mattieg1200 wrote:u have to say though.. was piques hand there before the ball was kicked into it ? if any had to be given it would have been that one but the rest were very soft.. and drogbas a bottle of shiraz cheating sherry anyway
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
did pique play the ball or did the ball play him??
get ova it
27th of May, Manchester United v Barcelona Champions League final Rome
get ova it
27th of May, Manchester United v Barcelona Champions League final Rome
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
Pique handball was a penalty if the referee saw it. If you look at the angle the ref had at the time you can see why he did not give it. Should have been the linesmans call!
- Punks Not Dead
- Apprentice
- Posts: 247
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2007 12:37 pm
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
MUFCBOY wrote:did pique play the ball or did the ball play him??
get ova it
27th of May, Manchester United v Barcelona Champions League final Rome
Actually it's Barcelona v manchester united.
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
thanks bodo.
If ye cannae dae the bouncy you're a Tim!
If ye cannae dae the bouncy you're a Tim!
If ye cannae dae the bouncy, cannae dae the bouncy,
Cannae dae the bouncy you're a Tim!
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
i would have given 3 penalties, 2 in 2st half within 3mins of each other and pique's handball. its history now but chelsea fans have every right to feel robbed
- Crocodiles
- Apprentice
- Posts: 215
- Joined: Sat Jul 05, 2008 7:12 am
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
He's a stickler for protocol.... sometimes!ruud wrote:The Finnish Flash wrote:thanks bodo.
There's people rolling around on the carpet, biting wool and pulling string
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
shhhhCrocodiles wrote:He's a stickler for protocol.... sometimes!ruud wrote:The Finnish Flash wrote:thanks bodo.
- El Pibe D'Oro
- Club Captain
- Posts: 6172
- Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 1:38 pm
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
1st - No
2nd -No
3rd No
4th - Yes one of the most obvious penalties ever
5th - Yes raise your arm in the box and the ball heading towards goal hits it?
2nd -No
3rd No
4th - Yes one of the most obvious penalties ever
5th - Yes raise your arm in the box and the ball heading towards goal hits it?
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
the fact that ppl r still debating this only means that the penalty wasnt 100% there
cause if it was we would all b agreeing
cause if it was we would all b agreeing
Re: Chelsea v Barca: The missed penalties
No people are debating it because they got beaten.
Tommy: We've lost Gorgeous George.
Brick Top: Well, where'd you lose him? He ain't a set of fucking car keys now, is he? And it ain't as if he's incon-fucking-spicuous now, is it?
Brick Top: Well, where'd you lose him? He ain't a set of fucking car keys now, is he? And it ain't as if he's incon-fucking-spicuous now, is it?