Brahma points deduction

[fowler_23]

Yes.. we are making other teams make these mistakes.

[SID]

Why are Easties to blame for others losing points?
If you break the rules you are penalised.
Can't penalise one team and let another team off with the same offense

[chunky-monkey]

Why are Easties to blame for others losing points?
If you break the rules you are penalised.
Can't penalise one team and let another team off with the same offense

And what offence is it that you're referring too?

[redfred]

same offence, different circumstance

[God is an Englishman]

The league are also to blame for this one. I've heard they've even admitted their error.

[sin²x + cos²x = 1]

How so?

[Bomber]

Get Griffen involved. Rightly or wrongly. :wink:

[God is an Englishman]

How so?

They originally sent out the wrong ban date. Brahna didn't play the guy on the correct date. Brahma are actually being punished for having correct records.

[Brian the Postman]

How so?

They originally sent out the wrong ban date. Brahna didn't play the guy on the correct date. Brahma are actually being punished for having correct records.

Wouldn't the correct date be the one that they advised by correspondence?

[God is an Englishman]

How so?

They originally sent out the wrong ban date. Brahna didn't play the guy on the correct date. Brahma are actually being punished for having correct records.

Wouldn't the correct date be the one that they advised by correspondence?

That is apparently the discussion that is in place. SAASL have admitted their error and that the game the player missed shoild have been the correct date.

I think that certainly muddies the waters significantly.

[FoundIt]

they get deducted 3 points, thats life in the saasl. you win some you lose some.

[Rodent]

I think Vista may be in trouble too after the weekends game

I think SID is referring to his former golden boy at Modbury, who lined up in the middle of the park for Vista on Sunday. As far as I'm aware he was not registered with anyone this year, therefore allowing Vista to sign.

true that.

Check that .....

[jogger]

Ouch

[Brian the Postman]

They originally sent out the wrong ban date. Brahna didn't play the guy on the correct date. Brahma are actually being punished for having correct records.

Wouldn't the correct date be the one that they advised by correspondence?

That is apparently the discussion that is in place. SAASL have admitted their error and that the game the player missed shoild have been the correct date.

I think that certainly muddies the waters significantly.

Are brahma relying on what is published on the website or the email correspondence?

[God is an Englishman]

I'm not involved with Brahma, I have no idea.

[Brian the Postman]

I'm not involved with Brahma, I have no idea.

Ok, I thought you were in the loop given your discussion so far.

[God is an Englishman]

I'm not involved with Brahma, I have no idea.

Ok, I thought you were in the loop given your discussion so far.

Maybe, the outer loop.

[Mr Red]

Better than being one of the Fruit Loops :wink:

[chunky-monkey]

Have seen Gardens awarded points from Vista game a couple weeks ago. Did also notice that an Inter player was on the susoended list on SAASL and played on weekend, was also one of the send offs. The league need to clear these situations up. Could be a third game in Div 1 where points are awarded to another team.

[God is an Englishman]

Major issue if SAASL will allow you to register someone and then 10 days later make a decision that the person shouldn't have been registered.

[chunky-monkey]

Major issue if SAASL will allow you to register someone and then 10 days later make a decision that the person shouldn't have been registered.

Agreed. Should flag up in that instance. Especially an honest mistake like this one where the player doesn't even know he is registered. Not like it was attempted to be hidden or be dodgy.

[haywood djablowme]

Have seen Gardens awarded points from Vista game a couple weeks ago. Did also notice that an Inter player was on the susoended list on SAASL and played on weekend, was also one of the send offs. The league need to clear these situations up. Could be a third game in Div 1 where points are awarded to another team.

please explain.. how about names??

You getting Marcus and Micky confused??

[chunky-monkey]

Have seen Gardens awarded points from Vista game a couple weeks ago. Did also notice that an Inter player was on the susoended list on SAASL and played on weekend, was also one of the send offs. The league need to clear these situations up. Could be a third game in Div 1 where points are awarded to another team.

please explain.. how about names??

You getting Marcus and Micky confused??

Maybe I have. I thought Michael was listed in the team Sunday?

[haywood djablowme]

Marcus was out suspended - accumulation of cards

Micky got sent off

[chunky-monkey]

Marcus was out suspended - accumulation of cards

Micky got sent off

My apologies. Too many brothers haha

[Guiseppe]

It does say on the website that micheal was suspended but could just be a mistake as there is so many of them haha

[haywood djablowme]

Email we rec'd said Marcus and we confirmed with league after seeing what was on the website.. good try boys :wink:

Good luck for the remainder of the year

[swannsong]

Major issue if SAASL will allow you to register someone and then 10 days later make a decision that the person shouldn't have been registered.

Unfortunately with the 'no communication' issue between the FFSA and SAASL, the onus is on the player to (a) know whether or not they were registered for another club, and (b) for the player to inform his/her new club that they were or weren't. (I guess the new club could also do some checking, but around the transfer window time things are often done in haste) Without that information, other clubs will look for the oversight for them...

[redfred]

how does a player not know he was registered?

[chunky-monkey]

how does a player not know he was registered?

Quite easily if the team goes and registers him after training once and he never goes back or plays a game.